Rumor Has It... (2005)

Rumor Has It... is the kind of glossy, grown-up romantic comedy that sneaks up on you: light on its feet, gently mischievous, and powered by a cast that knows exactly how to make banter feel like oxygen. Jennifer Aniston gives Sarah a relatable, itchy restlessness, while Kevin Costner brings an easy charm that keeps the movie humming, and Shirley MacLaine practically purrs with wit and mischief whenever she’s on screen. The vibe is sunny and slightly scandalous—more “family secrets over cocktails” than big, sappy declarations—and it delivers steady laughs without trying too hard. It won’t convert anyone who wants razor-sharp satire or deep drama, but if you’re on the fence and craving something watchable, warm, and effortlessly entertaining, this is a very pleasant bet.

Rumor Has It... is clearly trying to be a glossy, slightly naughty rom-com with a clever hook: family secrets, identity doubts, and a wink at famous literary gossip. The problem is it rarely commits to any one tone, so the story feels muddled and the comedy lands softer than it should, with direction that often feels oddly sleepy for material begging for spark. If you want sharp laughs or a truly swoony romance, this may feel lightweight and a bit bland, like it’s coasting on its premise rather than delivering on it. That said, the cast is game and occasionally charming, so it can work as low-stakes background viewing if your expectations are firmly set to “pleasant enough.”