Raintree County (1957)
In 1859, idealist John Wickliff Shawnessey, a resident of Raintree County, Indiana, is distracted from his high school sweetheart Nell Gaither by Susanna Drake, a rich New Orleans girl. This love triangle is further complicated by the American Civil War, and dark family history.
What people think about Raintree County
Raintree County is the kind of old-Hollywood epic that sweeps you up on sheer atmosphere: a lavish, dreamlike romance set against a nation about to tear itself in two, photographed with such painterly grandeur it feels like you’re watching memory itself. The film’s real seduction is sensory—sumptuous color, velvety cinematography, and a haunting score that lingers like perfume—while its emotions stay grounded in performances that take the melodrama seriously, especially Elizabeth Taylor, who gives a fierce, complicated turn that keeps the story vibrating with danger and longing. It’s less a tidy historical lesson than a moody, operatic reverie about love, obsession, and the costs of idealism as the Civil War shadows everything. If you’re allergic to sprawling, old-fashioned prestige dramas, it may feel overripe, but if you want a romantic epic you can sink into, this one rewards your patience with genuine, bruised beauty.
Raintree County is clearly aiming for an epic, Gone with the Wind-style romance that uses the Civil War as a backdrop for big emotions, big themes, and big tragedy. The problem is it’s sprawling to the point of shapeless, with a script that feels vague and unfocused, so scenes drift by without the story ever tightening its grip. If you’re allergic to slow pacing and don’t have patience for three hours of handsome but often tedious melodrama, this will test you. That said, the production looks gorgeous and the cast brings real commitment, so if you’re in the mood for vintage Hollywood spectacle more than narrative clarity, you may still find it worthwhile.
Cast
Elizabeth TaylorSusanna Drake Shawnessy
Montgomery CliftJohn Wickliff Shawnessy
Eva Marie SaintNell Gaither
Nigel PatrickProf. Jerusalem Webster Stiles
Lee MarvinOrville 'Flash' Perkins
Rod TaylorGarwood B. Jones
Agnes MooreheadEllen Shawnessy
Walter AbelT.D. Shawnessy
Jarma LewisBarbara Drake
Tom DrakeBobby Drake
Rhys WilliamsEzra Gray
Russell CollinsNiles Foster
DeForest KelleySouthern Officer- EEileen StevensMiss Roman
- LLuana LeeGirl (uncredited)
Sue GeorgeUndetermined Secondary Role (uncredited)
Myrna HansenMrs. Lydia Gray (uncredited)
Fred AldrichTownsman (uncredited)
Crew
- Director
- Edward Dmytryk
- Writers
- Millard Kaufman
- Producers
- David Lewis
- Music
- Johnny Green
- Cinematography
- Robert Surtees
- Editing
- John D. Dunning
Details
- Released
- December 20, 1957
- Language
- English
- Studio
- Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer
- IMDb
- tt0050882
